Why Did My Mortgage Payment Go Up? (Escrow and Property Taxes)

If you have a fixed-rate loan and your payment went up, the cause is almost always escrow. Escrow is the part of your payment that pays property taxes and homeowners insurance. When taxes or insurance go up, your servicer's yearly escrow review raises your payment. If the account came up short, federal rules say that for a shortage of one month's escrow payment or more, the servicer can only ask you to repay it over at least 12 months, though you may choose to pay it sooner. The servicer may also keep a cushion of up to one-sixth of a year's escrow bills.

Many new owners in Nashville see their payment jump after the first year. Often the escrow was set up using the old tax bill, and the new bill is higher. In Davidson County, a reappraisal can also change your home's value for tax purposes.

Federal escrow rules (RESPA, Regulation X)

RuleWhat it means for you
Yearly reviewYour servicer must review the escrow account and send a yearly statement within 30 days of the end of the escrow year
CushionThe servicer may hold extra, up to 1/6 of the year's escrow bills (about two months)
Shortage of 1 month's escrow or moreThe servicer may do nothing, or spread it over at least 12 equal monthly payments
Shortage under 1 month's escrowThe servicer may do nothing, ask for it within 30 days, or spread it over at least 12 months
Surplus of $50 or moreGenerally refunded to you within 30 days of the review

Example

Simple math to show why the payment can jump twice. It is not your actual bill.

Amount
Property tax goes up by$1,200 a year
New tax cost added each month+$100
Last year's shortage of $1,200, spread over 12 months+$100 (for one year)
Total increase for the next yearabout $200 a month, then about $100 after the shortage is paid

The Nashville reappraisal

The Davidson County Assessor mailed new 2025 reappraisal values on April 18, 2025. The state certifies a tax rate after a reappraisal so the county does not get a windfall from existing homes. Your own bill can still go up if your home's value rose more than average or if Metro changes the tax rate. If you think your value is wrong, the Assessor's office explains how to request a review or appeal by the posted deadlines.

What you can do

  • Read your escrow statement line by line. Look for the tax and insurance amounts.
  • Check your tax bill with the county. Ask your servicer to fix any error.
  • Shop your homeowners insurance.
  • Pay a shortage in one lump sum if you would rather keep the monthly payment lower.

Common questions

Why did my fixed-rate mortgage payment go up?

Your interest rate did not change. Your escrow did, because your property taxes or homeowners insurance went up.

What is an escrow shortage?

It means the escrow account did not collect enough last year to pay the bills. Your servicer finds it in the yearly review.

Do I have to pay an escrow shortage all at once?

No. If the shortage is one month's escrow or more, federal rules let the servicer only spread it over at least 12 months. You can choose to pay it early.

Can my servicer keep extra money in escrow?

Yes, a cushion of up to one-sixth of the year's escrow bills, which is about two months.

Why did my taxes go up after I bought?

The escrow may have used the old tax bill. A reappraisal or a rate change can also raise your bill.

Can I appeal my Davidson County property value?

Yes. The Assessor's office explains how to request a review and appeal. Watch the deadlines each year.

Talk it through

Confused by an escrow letter, or buying and want a better tax estimate up front? Call me at (615) 495-6594, email travis@heathrowmtg.com, or start an application.

Sources

Checked October 11, 2026. The example is simple math for illustration. Appeal deadlines change each year; check the Assessor's site.